Skip to main content
Dozens of NDP members have been blocked by the party from running in recent years. On September 22 my campaign sent this letter to all NDP leadership candidates. Responses below.
Dear _____,
My name is Yves Engler and I am running for leader of the New Democratic Party. I am reaching out to other leadership candidates to raise urgent concerns about our party’s democracy.
In recent years, it has become clear that “vetting” processes have blocked candidates not because of any crime or transgression they may have committed, but as a form of political censorship to prevent those with differing views from participating at all. This is an abuse of power. These processes were initially justified as a means of preventing surprises during election campaigns. This is not how they have been used. In recent campaigns we have seen potential candidates blocked simply for opposing the illegal Israeli occupation of Palestine. This history looms large today, as the people of Gaza face genocide.
Let’s be clear, democracy is our vetting process for political differences.
Blocking candidates that express different opinions from nomination races is a fundamental threat to the democracy of this party. If only candidates that “toe the line” are allowed, then our democracy is transformed into a superficial echo-chamber. We do not need depoliticized nomination races, where the only thing to discuss is the cosmetic qualities of the candidates. We are supposed to be the New DEMOCRATIC Party.
It is in this context that I raise the issue of my candidacy today. Since the day I announced my intention to run for leader, a loud chorus of right-wing pundits from the pro-genocide lobby have called for me to be “vetted out” of this race. A broad campaign is underway to ensure that New Democrats are never allowed to debate the ideas that I am bringing to the table. If we can’t discuss issues like capitalism, imperialism and genocide during a leadership race, then when can we? If we are not allowed to put forward criticisms of our party, how can it ever change?
I am writing today to ask for your support in ensuring a robust leadership race, where a wide range of views can be democratically debated. I am asking you today to speak out against the calls of the genocide lobby to disrupt our party’s democracy.
I am sending this letter to all who have openly expressed their interest in running for leader of the NDP to ask you to stand up for democracy in our party. I support your right to participate in this race, and I hope you will support mine. Together we can rebuild a vibrant, democratic party, where all progressive voices and working class tendencies are welcome.
In Solidarity,
Yves Engler
Please note: this letter and the responses we receive to it will be published.”
__
Tony McQuail was the only NDP leadership candidate who responded (Heather McPherson suggested in a National Post interview that she wasn’t against me running). In response McQuail wrote:
“I am looking forward to hearing the ideas and policy positions of all the leadership candidates. I am hoping I can learn from them and perhaps I will have something to share with each of you.
I have become increasingly uncomfortable with the NDP’s vetting process which has eliminated candidates from our local riding nomination processes.
Certainly, for the leadership of the New Democratic Party, the decision of what are acceptable ideas and policy positions should be in the hands of the membership when they vote in the leadership election. The NDP membership should not be pre-empted by a vetting procedure or committee. And the vetting committee should never be influenced by what is acceptable to individuals and organizations who would never support the NDP.
I look forward to hearing your thoughts and proposals during the course of the leadership campaign. I believe we all have an obligation to speak out against and act against genocide. As a citizen I do a Thursday morning vigil at the intersection of Creek Line and Highway 86 and writing letters to the editor. Our country could be doing so much more.”
Translate »